Manchester City and the alleged Premier League 'red cartel'
Verdict: Mostly accurate on the known facts, but it mixes verified reporting with speculation.
Credibility score: 66/100 · 11 claims checked · 10 accurate, 1 misleading, 0 false, 0 unsupported.
YouTube · Unknown · Unknown · Nov 6, 2026
The video accurately recounts several real events around the 2017 dinner photo and City’s financial case, but it overstates the cartel narrative and includes some unsupported inference.
Claim-by-claim breakdown
- Accurate (96% confidence): A 2017 New York dinner photograph showed Liverpool owner John W. Henry, Manchester United executive Ed Woodward, Arsenal chief executive Ivan Gazidis, and the Glazers. ESPN’s reporting on the 'red cartel' story identifies Henry, Woodward, Gazidis, and the Glazers in the New York dinner photo.
- Accurate (92% confidence): Manchester City, Tottenham Hotspur, and Chelsea were not represented at that dinner meeting. Coverage of the dinner notes that City, Tottenham, and Chelsea were not present.
- Accurate (90% confidence): The dinner took place in October 2017 at a New York restaurant co-owned by Robert De Niro. The reported meeting was photographed in October 2017 at Locanda Verde, a New York restaurant co-owned by Robert De Niro.
- Accurate (78% confidence): The meeting happened shortly before a Premier League vote on future broadcasting revenue. The story has been reported as taking place about a week before a Premier League vote tied to future broadcasting revenue.
- Accurate (98% confidence): Manchester City were charged by the Premier League in February 2023 with 115 alleged breaches of financial regulations covering 2009 to 2018. The Premier League announced 115 alleged breaches in February 2023 spanning 2009-10 through 2017-18.
- Accurate (95% confidence): An independent commission found Manchester City guilty of 114 of those charges. The Premier League said an independent commission found City guilty of 114 of the 115 charges.
- Accurate (94% confidence): Manchester City deny wrongdoing and have appealed the commission’s decision. City publicly rejected the allegations and reporting says the club is pursuing an appeal.
- Accurate (97% confidence): There is no established finding that Liverpool, Manchester United, and Arsenal formed a cartel to undermine Manchester City. No authoritative finding establishes a cartel; the claim remains an allegation and interpretation.
- Accurate (93% confidence): Arsène Wenger publicly questioned Manchester City’s sponsorship valuations and financial fair play in 2011. Reporting from 2011 describes Wenger accusing City of bending UEFA fair-play rules over a large sponsorship deal.
- Accurate (91% confidence): John W. Henry posted a tweet in 2011 suggesting a club’s best player should be worth a meaningful share of naming-rights value. Reporting quotes Henry saying a club’s best player should be worth at least 10% of naming-rights value.
- Misleading (84% confidence): The video implies the dinner meeting is evidence of coordination against Manchester City. The existence of the dinner does not prove a cartel or coordinated effort against City; the inference is speculative.
More fact-checks
- BJP with Bharat on Instagram: "My Bengal is healing 🥹🪷 79 years after Independence, an elderly couple in Namkhana, South 24 Parganas, finally received electricity in their home. Imagine spending almost an entire lifetime without one of the most basic necessities of modern civilisation. For decades, successive Congress, Left Front and TMC governments failed to ensure that even this basic requirement reached every household. What a shameful reflection of governance! But the story also highlights what accountable leadership and ground-level intervention can achieve. BJP MLA Sumanta Mondal took up the couple's issue and helped facilitate their electricity connection. This is precisely the kind of people-centric approach Bengal needs, where public representatives focus on solving real problems instead of merely making political promises. With BJP now forming the government in West Bengal, people have renewed expectations of development, accountability and better delivery of essential services. No elderly couple should have to wait eight decades for electricity. Development is meaningful only when it reaches the last household, and every citizen deserves dignity, opportunity and basic facilities. #westbengal #bjp #tmc #modi #diwali" — Score 58/100
- Jamaica political rant over hurricane relief and government criticism — Score 34/100
- Comments on UK anti-Muslim hostility definition and police responses — Score 48/100
- France, Covid, dette et Bruno Le Maire — Score 38/100
- Instagram reel by Zach (Net Worth) — Score 58/100
- 463K views · 1K reactions | The one who runs away from debate in Parliament, wants to debate! 😑 | The-Pulse — Score 45/100
- Leo Siqueira | Economista & Deputado. on Instagram: "Siga @leosiqueirabr O dólar sobe lá fora e a conta chega no seu prato." — Score 78/100
- Narundar on Instagram: "Disrespecting Lord Krishna to praise Lord Ram... Doesn't know anything about religion but have become religious Gurus, calls god tera wala mera wala while both are incarnations of Lord Vishnu." — Score 88/100